If you or someone you love has been accused of breaking the law in Indiana, the process you face will depend on whether you are treated as an adult or as a juvenile. While both systems deal with criminal behavior, they are built on different principles. Adults face punishment meant to hold them accountable, while juveniles often encounter a system focused on rehabilitation.
Learning about how these processes differ can help you know what to expect and why the outcome of a juvenile case may look very different from an adult prosecution.
Table of Contents
The Juvenile Justice System
Juvenile cases in Indiana begin when a minor, usually under the age of 18, is accused of committing a “delinquent offense.” These offenses would be crimes if committed by an adult, but the procedures for handling them are different.
Juvenile proceedings are held in juvenile court, not adult criminal court. Instead of a jury trial, cases are typically decided by a judge. The process is also less formal, and the focus is on finding solutions that guide young people back on track rather than branding them with a permanent criminal record.
What Are Common Outcomes in Juvenile Criminal Cases?
A range of outcomes is possible, including:
- Probation
- Counseling
- Community service
- Juvenile detention
- Treatment programs
Judges look at the individual child’s needs and the best way to support rehabilitation.
The Adult Criminal Process
Adults in Indiana accused of crimes face a very different system. Their cases move through traditional criminal courts, which are often open to the public. Defendants may be entitled to a jury trial, and the rules of evidence are applied strictly.
The main goal in adult criminal cases is punishment. A conviction can result in jail or prison time, fines, probation, and other penalties. Records of adult convictions are generally public and can follow someone for years, leading to serious collateral consequences.
Unlike the juvenile process, adult sentencing focuses less on rehabilitation and more on ensuring accountability and deterrence.
When Juveniles Can Be Tried as Adults
Although most minors are handled in the juvenile system, Indiana law allows certain cases to be transferred to adult court. This can happen if the alleged offense is especially serious, such as a violent felony, or if the juvenile has prior delinquent findings.
When a case is waived into adult court, the juvenile is treated much like any other defendant. This means exposure to the same penalties, the same criminal record, and the same long-term consequences. The decision to move a case from juvenile to adult court is significant and can dramatically change a young person’s future.
Rights and Protections in Each System
Both adults and juveniles have rights when facing criminal allegations. These include the right to legal counsel and protection against self-incrimination. However, the way those rights are applied differs between the two systems.
For juveniles, hearings are often more private, and the court has greater discretion in determining the outcome. For adults, the system is more rigid, with strict sentencing guidelines and limited flexibility.
Understanding how these distinctions work is important because it shapes not only how the case is handled but also what life may look like after the proceedings are over.
What Impact Could These Differences Have on My Case?
The differences between adult and juvenile processes highlight the competing goals of punishment and rehabilitation. A juvenile who makes a mistake may have the chance to move forward without carrying a permanent record. An adult, on the other hand, may face penalties that last long after they have completed their sentence.
For families, knowing which system applies can help set expectations and guide decisions about legal representation. For defendants, the system you are placed in can influence both the process you face and the opportunities available for a fresh start.
How a Criminal Defense Lawyer Can Help if You’ve Been Accused of Committing a Crime
Having a criminal defense lawyer in your corner is essential, whether the case involves a juvenile or an adult.
A lawyer can:
- Review the charges and evidence against you
- Explain the differences between adult and juvenile court procedures
- Advocate for keeping a juvenile case within the juvenile system when possible
- Protect constitutional rights at every stage
- Work toward outcomes that minimize long-term harm
For adults, this may mean challenging the evidence or negotiating a reduced sentence. For juveniles, it may mean ensuring the court focuses on rehabilitation rather than punishment.
Contact the Indianapolis Criminal Defense Lawyers at Suhre & Associates DUI and Criminal Defense Lawyers for Help Today
If you or your child is facing criminal charges in Indiana, it’s critical to remember that you’re innocent until proven guilty. Knowing the differences between adult and juvenile systems is only the first step. A skilled defense lawyer can protect your rights and work for the best possible outcome in either setting.
Contact an Indianapolis criminal defense attorney at Suhre & Associates DUI and Criminal Defense Lawyers today at (317) 759-2599 to discuss your case and schedule a free consultation. The right guidance can make all the difference in protecting your future.
